Loan Comparison Guide

SBA 504 vs Conventional Commercial Mortgage: Cost and Fit

SBA 504 vs a conventional bank mortgage for buying your own building: down payment, rate, fees, eligibility and what each owes at year 10, with a $2M example.

By BestLoanUSA Updated 5 min read

A business buying the building it operates from usually ends up choosing between two structures: an SBA 504 loan, which splits the purchase between a bank first mortgage and a fixed-rate loan from a Certified Development Company (CDC) backed by the SBA, and a conventional commercial mortgage — one bank loan, no government guarantee.

The headline difference is the down payment, and our SBA 504 loans page already shows what that does to the monthly payment. This guide looks at the rest of the decision: who can use each loan, what each costs beyond the rate, how long each takes, and — the part most comparisons skip — how much you still owe, and must refinance, ten years in.

Side-by-Side: Typical Terms

Typical ranges on our loan pages (September 2026). Your terms depend on the property, the business and the lenders.

SBA 504Conventional commercial mortgage
StructureBank first mortgage (about 50%) + CDC/SBA loan (about 40%) + your equityOne bank loan + your equity
Interest rate6.25–7.25%; CDC portion fixed for its full term6.5–8%, fixed or variable, set by the bank
FinancingUp to 90% of project costLTV of 65–75% (80% multifamily)
Down payment10%; 15% or 20% in the cases below25–35%
Term10–25 yr on the CDC loan, fully amortizing5–10 yr term, 20–30 yr amortization, balloon at maturity
Time to close60–90 days30–45 days
Who can use itOwner-occupying, for-profit small businesses onlyOwner-users and investors

Eligibility: Where the 504 Draws Hard Lines

A conventional mortgage is underwritten to the bank’s own policy. A 504 loan has to meet federal program rules first, and several of them decide the question before rates do:

  • You must occupy the building. At least 51% of an existing building, and at least 60% of a newly built one at the start, with all space it does not permanently lease (up to 20%) occupied within 10 years. A building you buy to lease out entirely does not qualify — that is a conventional, DSCR or other investor loan.
  • Ownership. Since March 1, 2026, every owner of the business must be a U.S. citizen or U.S. national residing in the United States; lawful permanent residents no longer qualify. A business with even one owner who is not a U.S. citizen or national, or who lives abroad, is a conventional borrower.
  • Size. The business must be small under SBA standards — under the alternative test, tangible net worth of $20 million or less and average net income after taxes of $6.5 million or less over the prior two years.
  • Equity. 10% of project cost, rising to 15% for a business two years old or less or a special-purpose building, and 20% if both apply. A conventional bank loan usually asks for 25–35% regardless.
  • A jobs or policy goal. Each 504 project must create or retain jobs — for loans approved since October 1, 2025, one job per $95,000 of SBA-backed loan ($150,000 for small manufacturers and energy projects) — or meet one of the program’s community development or public policy goals.
  • Guarantees. Owners of 20% or more personally guarantee the loan. Most conventional owner-user loans ask for a personal guarantee too, so this is rarely the deciding factor.

Loan size cuts the other way. The CDC/SBA portion is capped at $5 million per business ($5.5 million per project for small manufacturers and certain energy projects), but there is no program cap on the bank’s first mortgage, so 504 projects can be much larger than $5 million.

Costs Beyond the Interest Rate

The two loans put their fees in different places:

  • 504: the CDC processing fee (up to 1.5% of the net debenture) and the SBA guarantee fee (0.5%), along with closing and funding fees, are mostly financed into the CDC loan rather than paid in cash. SBA also charges the bank a one-time 0.5% fee on its first mortgage; ask whether the bank passes it on. The fee breakdown is on our 504 page.
  • Conventional: the bank’s origination fee, appraisal, environmental report and legal costs, usually paid at closing.

Prepayment works differently too. The CDC portion carries a prepayment premium during its first 10 years (first 5 on a 10-year loan) — roughly one year of interest at the start, stepping down each year to zero from year 11. A conventional loan’s penalty is whatever the bank negotiates: a step-down, yield maintenance or none (see commercial loan prepayment penalties). If you might sell within a few years, price both.

Worked Example: What You Owe at Year 10

An established business buys a $2,000,000 general-purpose building it will occupy. Assumptions for illustration only, the same as on our 504 page: a 6.5% CDC rate fixed for 25 years and a 7.0% bank rate on a 25-year amortization for the 504 bank loan; for the conventional loan, 25% down at 7.0%, 25-year amortization and a 10-year term. Figures from our SBA 504 calculator and commercial mortgage calculator; 504 fees financed into the CDC loan are not included.

SBA 504Conventional (25% down)
Cash down$200,000$500,000
LoansBank $1,000,000 + CDC $800,000Bank $1,500,000
Monthly payment$12,469 (bank $7,068 + CDC $5,402, each rounded)$10,602
Balance after 10 yearsBank $786,334 + CDC $620,091$1,179,501
Due at year 10$786,334 if the bank loan has a 10-year term; the CDC loan keeps amortizing$1,179,501 — the whole loan

Two things stand out. The 504 borrower kept $300,000 more cash at closing and pays $1,867 more a month for it. And at year 10 the 504 borrower has a smaller refinance to arrange: SBA requires the bank loan in a 20- or 25-year 504 to run at least 10 years, but it can still end in a balloon, while the CDC loan runs on at its fixed rate. The conventional borrower must refinance or repay the full $1,179,501 at whatever rates prevail then. With a 5-year conventional term, the same loan would leave $1,367,432 due at year 5.

The conventional loan, in exchange, leaves less total debt: $1,179,501 against $1,406,425 for the 504 at year 10, because the 504 borrower started with $300,000 more of it.

Which Fits

The 504 usually fits when the business will occupy most of the building for many years, keeping cash matters more than the lowest payment, the owners and business meet the program rules, and a 60–90 days close works for the seller.

A conventional mortgage usually fits when the property is mostly leased to others, any owner is not a U.S. citizen or national, the purchase has to close within 30–45 days, you expect to sell or refinance within a few years, or you have the down payment and want a single lender and one set of documents.

Some buyers compare a third option, the SBA 7(a), which also finances real estate and can include working capital in the same loan — see SBA 7(a) vs SBA 504. For the broader owner-user picture, including the lease-versus-buy decision, see owner-occupied commercial real estate loans.

We work with 30+ lenders, including banks that make conventional owner-user loans and lenders that work with CDCs on 504s, and there is no hard credit pull to start. Start an application and we will price your purchase both ways; you get a decision within 48 hours.

💡 Before choosing, put both offers on one page: cash at closing, monthly payment, total fees, prepayment terms and the balance due at the first maturity. The loan with the lower payment is not always the one with less risk.

Sources: 13 CFR 120.131 (occupancy); SBA Policy Notice 5000-876441 (ownership, effective March 1, 2026); 13 CFR 121.301 (alternative size standard); 13 CFR 120.910 (borrower contribution); SBA, “Development Company Loan Program — Job Creation and Retention Requirements,” 90 FR 47117 (Sept. 30, 2025); 15 U.S.C. 696 (debenture limits); 13 CFR 120.921 (third-party loan term); 13 CFR 120.971–120.972 (CDC and participation fees); 13 CFR 120.940 (prepayment of the 504 loan).

The bottom line

Choose by the constraint that binds you. If cash is the constraint and you will occupy the building for the long haul, the 504 stretches your equity further and leaves less to refinance later. If time, eligibility or flexibility is the constraint, a conventional mortgage is simpler — just plan for the balloon from the day you close.

Run the numbers

Keep reading