Loan Comparison Guide

Commercial Mortgage Broker vs Going Direct to a Bank

Commercial mortgage broker or your own bank? What each does, how brokers are paid, why banks decline good deals, and how to weigh a fee against a rate.

By BestLoanUSA Updated 7 min read

When a business owner or investor needs a commercial real estate loan, there are two ways to start. You can go direct: call the bank that holds your operating account, or a few lenders you find yourself, and apply with each. Or you can use a commercial mortgage broker, who takes one package from you and shows it to lenders whose programs fit the property and the borrower.

A note before the comparison: BestLoanUSA sits on the broker side of this choice. We do not lend; when a loan closes, we may receive part of the broker fee paid on it, disclosed in writing before you sign. The facts below — how banks set limits, how broker pay works, how to compare a fee against a rate — hold whichever route you take, and the questions at the end are the ones we would want a borrower to ask us.

Side-by-Side

Going direct to a bankUsing a broker
Who decides and fundsThe bankThe lender you choose — the broker does neither
Lenders that see the dealThe ones you apply to yourselfSeveral, chosen by property type, size and borrower profile
Whose limits applyThat bank’s lending limit, CRE concentration and credit policyEach lender’s own — a decline at one does not close the others
Who pays for the arrangingNo one; the bank’s cost is in its rate and feesThe lender, the borrower, or both — get it in writing
RelationshipBuilds one; the bank may ask you to move depositsYour relationship is with the lender after closing
Your timeOne application per lenderOne package; the broker answers lender questions with you

What a Broker Does — and Does Not Do

A commercial mortgage broker reads the deal (property, cash flow, borrower, purpose), decides which kinds of lenders are likely to take it — banks, credit unions, SBA lenders, life companies, CMBS, debt funds — presents it to them, and brings back term sheets for you to compare. A broker does not approve the loan, set the final terms or fund it; the lender does all three, under its own underwriting.

Brokers are paid in one of three ways: by the lender, out of the loan’s pricing; by the borrower, as a fee at closing; or both. None is improper, but you should know which before you sign anything. Federal Regulation Z — the Truth in Lending rules, including its loan-originator compensation rules — does not apply to credit extended primarily for business or commercial purposes, so no federal form will show you the broker’s pay on a commercial loan. Ask for it in a signed fee agreement: the amount or percentage, who pays it, when it is earned, and whether anything is owed if the loan does not close.

Licensing is set by each state. California, for example, defines anyone who solicits borrowers or lenders for, or negotiates, loans secured by real property — for compensation — as a real estate broker (Business and Professions Code §10131(d)), and acting as one requires a license unless an exemption applies. Ask a broker which license they hold and check it on the state regulator’s website.

Why a Bank Can Decline a Good Deal

A “no” from your own bank is not always about your property or your finances. Three limits sit above any one loan officer:

  • Lending limit. A national bank’s total loans to one borrower generally cannot exceed 15% of its unimpaired capital and surplus (12 U.S.C. 84), counting all loans to you and borrowers whose debts are combined with yours. At a bank with $40 million of capital and surplus, that is $6,000,000 across everything you owe it — a ceiling a growing investor can reach. State-chartered banks follow their own state’s limits.
  • CRE concentration. Under the federal banking agencies’ 2006 guidance, a bank whose construction, land and development loans reach 100% of its total risk-based capital, or whose total CRE loans (construction, multifamily and other investor CRE) reach 300% of it and have grown 50% or more in the prior 36 months, is expected to run heightened risk management. A bank near those lines may slow new investor CRE lending, whatever the quality of the next deal.
  • Loan-to-value and policy. Banks set LTV limits under the interagency real estate lending guidelines (see bridge loan vs hard money) and their own lists of property types, markets and loan sizes they will do.

When a bank declines, you can get the reasons. Regulation B applies to business credit: if your business had gross revenues of $1 million or less in its last fiscal year, the lender must tell you of the decision within 30 days of a completed application and, if it declines, give you the reasons or tell you of your right to ask for them. Larger businesses must be told the decision within a reasonable time and can get the reasons in writing by asking in writing within 60 days.

What Going Direct Does Well

  • The relationship. A bank that already knows your deposits and history may move faster on a deal that fits its policy, and the loan officer you deal with is the one who will handle renewals.
  • Relationship pricing. Banks are allowed to condition credit or vary its price on your also taking a loan, deposit or trust service from them — federal anti-tying law makes an exception for these traditional bank products (12 U.S.C. 1972). Expect to be asked to move operating accounts, and price the loan with that in mind.
  • No one in the middle. If the deal is plain — a stabilized property, a modest loan, a bank that wants it — there is no one else’s fee to pay and no one else to coordinate.

What a Broker Does Well

  • Reach past one bank’s limits. A deal above your bank’s lending limit, in a property type it avoids, or arriving when its CRE book is full can still fit another lender’s program.
  • Comparable offers. Several term sheets on the same deal show you what the market will do on rate, leverage, fees, prepayment and recourse.
  • Packaging. A complete package — rent roll, operating statements, entity documents, sources and uses — answers the questions underwriters would otherwise send back one at a time.

A broker cannot make a lender approve a loan it would not otherwise make, and no broker can promise a particular rate. Treat any such promise, or a large fee due before a lender has issued terms, as a warning sign (see red flags in a business loan offer).

Worked Example: A Lower Rate With a Higher Fee

Whichever route you take, you will often face this choice: one offer has a lower rate but costs more at closing — whether the extra cost is a broker’s fee or a lender’s origination fee. Assumptions for illustration only: a $2,000,000 purchase with 30% down, so a $1,400,000 loan on a 25-year amortization and a 10-year term. Offer A is 7.00% with no extra fee; Offer B is 6.75% with an extra 1% ($14,000) at closing. Figures from our commercial mortgage calculator and refinance break-even calculator.

Offer A: 7.00%Offer B: 6.75% + $14,000
Monthly payment$9,895$9,673
Balance after 3 years$1,330,991$1,328,484
Balance after 5 years$1,276,270$1,272,122
Balance due at year 10$1,100,868$1,093,079

Offer B saves about $222 a month, so on payments alone the $14,000 takes about 63 months to recover. Counting the lower balance as well, the fee still loses if you sell or refinance at year 3 (about $7,997 of payments saved plus a $2,507 lower balance, against $14,000), is about $3,477 ahead at year 5, and about $20,446 ahead at year 10. The lower rate is worth paying for only if you expect to keep the loan past roughly year four — and a prepayment penalty can change that answer again.

Questions to Ask Either Side

  • A broker: Who pays you, how much, and when is it earned? Is anything due if the loan does not close? Which lenders will see my deal, and will you tell me before it goes to each one? Which license do you hold? (For how to check the answers, see how to choose a commercial mortgage broker.)
  • A bank: Is this loan within your lending limit and appetite for this property type right now? What deposits or other accounts do you expect? What are the prepayment terms and the balloon date?
  • Both: When will my credit be pulled, and by whom? (See hard vs soft credit inquiries.) Can I see every fee — origination, broker, processing, legal, third-party reports — on one page before I sign?

Which Fits

Going direct usually fits when your bank already knows you, the property and loan size sit well inside its policy, and you are comfortable moving or keeping deposits there.

A broker usually fits when the loan is large relative to your bank, the property or plan is outside what your bank does, your bank has declined or gone quiet, or you want several written offers on the same deal before choosing. You can also do both: ask your bank first and compare its offer with what the wider market sends back.

We work with 30+ lenders, charge $0 upfront fees, show our compensation in writing before you sign, and there is no hard credit pull to start. If you already have an offer from your bank, start an application and we will set it side by side with what other lenders offer on the same deal; you get a decision within 48 hours.

💡 Put every offer — your bank’s and any a broker brings — on one page: rate, every fee and who receives it, prepayment terms, recourse and the balance due at the first maturity. Then run the numbers for the number of years you actually expect to keep the loan.

Sources: 12 U.S.C. 84 and 12 CFR part 32 (national bank lending limits, OCC); Concentrations in Commercial Real Estate Lending, Sound Risk Management Practices, 71 FR 74580 (Dec. 12, 2006; OCC, Federal Reserve, FDIC); Interagency Guidelines for Real Estate Lending Policies, 12 CFR part 34, subpart D, appendix A; 12 CFR 1002.9(a) (Regulation B notifications, including business credit); 12 U.S.C. 1972 and 12 CFR 225.7 (anti-tying and the traditional bank product exception); 12 CFR 1026.3(a) (Regulation Z business-purpose exemption); Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code §10131(d). Example figures computed with the site’s commercial mortgage and refinance break-even calculator code.

The bottom line

Neither route is cheaper by default. Ask each side the same questions in writing — who pays whom, how much, and what happens if the loan does not close — then compare the offers on total cost over the years you expect to hold the loan, not on rate alone.

Run the numbers

Keep reading