Commercial Real Estate Legal

Completion Guarantee

Completion Guarantee, in short

A completion guarantee is a construction lender's backstop. The guarantor promises the building will be finished, lien-free and per the approved plans, and pays whatever the remaining loan funds cannot cover if costs overrun or the project stalls. It typically ends at completion, such as the certificate of occupancy and final lien waivers, unlike a repayment guarantee, which usually continues.

Also called completion guarantyguaranty of completioncost overrun guarantyconstruction completion guaranty

How a completion guarantee works

A construction lender funds a project that does not exist yet. The collateral is land plus a building that is some percentage finished, and a half-built building is worth far less than the cost already poured into it. If the money runs out before the certificate of occupancy, the lender's choices are bad: fund the gap itself, finish construction as an unwilling developer, or sell an unfinished asset.

The completion guarantee exists to avoid that. A creditworthy party, usually the sponsor's principal or a parent company, promises the lender that the improvements will be completed in line with the approved plans and specifications and free of mechanic's liens. If the undisbursed loan proceeds are not enough to get there, the guarantor covers the difference. It is often called a cost overrun guaranty because that is where it does most of its work.

Lenders usually define completion by checklist rather than by a feeling that the building looks done. The checklist commonly centers on a certificate of occupancy, work finished per the approved plans and lien-free completion, and it may also include final permits, final lien waivers, utility connections, final architect or engineer certification and tenant improvements, depending on the document. Read that definition closely, because the guarantee does not end until every item is checked.

What it covers, and what it does not

A typical completion guarantee makes the guarantor responsible for lien-free completion and for cost overruns. It also commonly reaches the non-construction costs of getting there, such as interest during construction, insurance premiums and real estate taxes, to the extent the loan does not cover them. Lenders differ on the exact scope, so the wording of your document governs, not this page.

  • Cost overruns. The gap between the real cost to finish and the money the loan has left to fund it.
  • Delay. Interest, taxes and insurance that keep accruing while a stalled project waits for a fix. Some lenders paper these carrying costs in a separate carry guaranty, and payment of contractors may sit in a separate payment guaranty, so check which document holds which promise.
  • Liens. Mechanic's and materialman's liens that attach during construction must be released or discharged.
  • Performance of the work. The obligation to build what was approved, not a cheaper version.

The guarantor's exposure is generally the cost of finishing the work per the approved plans minus the loan proceeds still undisbursed, though caps and structure vary by document. It is a promise about the building, not about the market. A completion guarantee generally does not make the guarantor answerable for the loan being repaid at maturity. That job belongs to a repayment guarantee, covered below.

Worked example

A developer plans a ground-up building with this budget: land $1,000,000, hard costs $3,000,000 and soft costs $500,000, for a total project cost of $4,500,000. The lender sizes the loan at 70% of cost, which is $3,150,000, and the sponsor funds the remaining $1,350,000 in equity. You can reproduce these figures in the site's loan-to-cost calculator by entering 70 as the maximum LTC. They are example assumptions, not a quote.

  • Total cost — $4,500,000
  • Loan at 70% of cost — $3,150,000
  • Sponsor equity — $1,350,000

Partway through, steel and labor prices rise and the hard costs come in 10% over budget, an extra $300,000. The loan commitment is fixed at $3,150,000 and the lender will not lend more. With no completion guarantee, the project simply cannot be finished with the money it has, and the lender holds a stalled project.

With a completion guarantee, the sponsor or guarantor must deposit that $300,000, or fund it as costs come due, before the lender will keep disbursing. This is the loan-in-balance requirement: the lender disburses only while the undisbursed loan is enough to complete the improvements and pay the project costs, and it may require additional borrower funds when revised or actual costs say it is not. The practical effect is that the sponsor's equity is not $1,350,000. It is $1,350,000 plus whatever the project costs beyond the budget.

Completion vs. repayment guarantee

Borrowers often hear both names in the same term sheet and assume they are one document. They are not.

  • Completion guarantee: about delivering the building. It typically expires when the building receives its certificate of occupancy and the other completion conditions are met.
  • Repayment guarantee: about the loan balance. It typically does not expire at completion, and may be reduced or released later when the project hits stated goals such as lien-free completion or stabilized occupancy. Provisions that step the guaranty down as milestones are met are often called burn-off provisions.

A construction loan can have either or both. Which one a lender asks for, or whether it asks for both, depends on the lender and the sponsor, so ask which guaranties are in the term sheet before you compare offers. For how the repayment side differs from the non-recourse structure used on stabilized assets, see non-recourse loan and personal guarantee. Non-recourse permanent debt still carries bad boy carve-outs, which are a separate document.

Why lenders care

For the lender, construction is the riskiest point in the life of a property. The loan is underwritten on a plan and a budget, and every dollar disbursed raises the amount at risk before the property has produced income. The completion guarantee answers the question the lender cares about most: who pays if the plan is wrong?

That is why the guarantor's balance sheet matters as much as the project. Lenders usually set liquidity and net worth requirements for the guarantor, and may keep them in force for as long as the guaranty is outstanding. They also look at the guarantor's other exposures, including contingent liabilities from other developments, existing guarantees and construction projects running at the same time. A sponsor with three buildings under construction who has signed three completion guarantees has promised the same cash three times. For more on how lenders underwrite the person behind the loan, see guarantor (key principal).

Completion risk also shapes how much a lender will lend. Our commercial construction loans page shows typical leverage of 65–80% LTC, terms of 12–24 mo and rates in the range of 6.75–10.5%. Read loan-to-cost for how the leverage is measured.

What lenders can do if the guarantor does not perform

Completion guaranties usually give the lender three remedies, and the document typically lets the lender choose among them:

  1. Make the guarantor complete. The guarantor must finish construction at its own cost.
  2. Complete it themselves. The lender finishes the project and recovers from the guarantor the cost above the undisbursed loan proceeds.
  3. Collect liquidated damages. The guarantor pays an amount equal to the estimated cost of completion. This gives the lender the most flexibility, because the lender can end the guarantor's involvement in the project and does not have to build anything itself.

Guaranties also tend to address what happens when the project, the schedule or the loan changes: modifications, extensions past the maturity date and rate changes. Guarantors typically waive certain legal defenses in the document. This is the part of the guaranty that gets read carefully only after something goes wrong, so have it read before.

Performance bonds and other protection

A sponsor's guarantee is not the only protection against a contractor who cannot finish. A performance bond issued by a surety to the general contractor protects the project owner, and the lender, who is not a party to the construction contract, generally needs a dual-obligee rider to have a direct right of action under it. Some lenders accept a bond in place of part of the sponsor's liability, and some require both. Whether you can negotiate the bond into a reduction in the guaranty is a point to raise at term sheet stage, not at closing.

Other common protections include a fixed-price or guaranteed-maximum-price contract, a contingency line in the budget, a third-party construction monitor who inspects each draw and a retainage holdback on contractor payments. They do not replace a completion guaranty, but a well-built set of them makes the lender less likely to call on it.

How to negotiate it

  • Fix the definition of completion. Ask for a short, objective checklist with a stated process for lender sign-off. An open-ended definition keeps the guaranty alive after the building is done.
  • Tie the guaranty to the budget you approved. Changes the lender requests or approves should adjust the budget the guarantor is measured against.
  • Ask for a burn-off. If a repayment guaranty is also required, ask that it step down or release at lien-free completion or stabilized occupancy.
  • Limit the liquidity covenant. A minimum-liquidity test that runs for the full life of the loan can force the guarantor to hold cash that could be working somewhere else. Negotiate a lower number or a shorter period once construction is complete.
  • Count your total exposure. If you have signed other guaranties, add them up before you sign another. Lenders will, and they can ask about it.
  • Get a cure period. Ask for time to fix a funding gap before the lender can call an event of default.

What to watch for

  • The guaranty can cost more than your equity. The cost-overrun promise is measured against the real cost to finish, not the budget you started with, unless the document sets a cap. Price the downside case before you agree, not after.
  • Individual guarantors are personally liable. If you sign as an individual rather than through an entity, your personal assets are exposed. Ask counsel how the guaranty is structured.
  • A completed building can still leave a lien. Lien-free is part of the promise. A disputed subcontractor claim that is not bonded off or discharged keeps the obligation open.
  • Stabilization is a separate risk. Finishing construction does not end the loan. See exit strategy, because the construction loan is repaid by a permanent loan or a sale, and that takeout is a second test.

If you are planning a ground-up project or a major renovation and want to understand which guaranties a lender will ask for, start an application with your budget and contractor bid and include the guaranty requirements from any term sheet you have.

Sources: Commercial Property Executive, "Navigating Construction Loans, Part 2" (commercialsearch.com); Mondaq/Lexology construction-law commentary on completion guaranties, exposure and remedies; Lever Capital, "Completion Guarantees: When Lenders Require Them"; Scotsman Guide, "Completion Versus Repayment Guarantees"; NASBP and Mondaq commentary on dual-obligee performance bonds. Example figures use the BestLoanUSA loan-to-cost calculator and are illustrative assumptions.

Frequently asked

What is a completion guarantee in construction lending?

It is a guaranty, signed by the sponsor or another creditworthy party, that the project will be completed in accordance with the approved plans and free of liens. If the loan proceeds that remain are not enough to finish the work, the guarantor must fund the shortfall or complete the project.

What is the difference between a completion guarantee and a repayment guarantee?

A completion guarantee is about finishing the building, and it typically expires when construction is complete, for example at the certificate of occupancy and final lien waivers. A repayment guarantee is about the loan balance, and it generally does not end at completion. Some loans carry both, and a repayment guaranty may be reduced as the project reaches milestones such as stabilized occupancy.

Who has to sign a completion guarantee?

Lenders ask for a creditworthy party, usually the sponsor's principal or a parent entity, and they typically test the guarantor's liquidity and net worth, sometimes for as long as the guaranty is in force. The lender also looks at the guarantor's other development projects and contingent liabilities.

What happens if the guarantor cannot finish the project?

Lenders commonly hold three remedies: require the guarantor to complete construction, complete it themselves and bill the guarantor for costs above the undisbursed loan funds, or collect liquidated damages based on the estimated cost of completion. Liquidated damages give the lender the most flexibility because it can remove the guarantor from the project.

Can a performance bond replace a completion guarantee?

Sometimes it supplements it. A performance bond on the general contractor protects the owner, and a lender usually needs a dual-obligee rider to have a direct right under it. Whether a bond reduces or replaces the sponsor's guaranty is a negotiated term of the loan.

Related terms