Commercial Real Estate Legal

Guarantor (Key Principal)

Guarantor (Key Principal), in short

A guarantor is who stands behind a commercial real estate loan personally or through a creditworthy entity. On non-recourse loans the guaranty is usually a carve-out guaranty, and agency lenders call the main guarantor the Key Principal. The lender underwrites the guarantor's net worth, verified liquidity, credit, and experience, and can require ongoing financial reporting for as long as the loan is outstanding.

Also called key principalkey borrower principalloan guarantorsponsorcarve-out guarantor

What a guarantor is, and why a lender wants one

Most commercial real estate is owned through a single-purpose LLC. That entity owns one building, has one lender, and has no other assets. If the property underperforms, the lender's recovery is limited to what the LLC owns. A guaranty adds a second source of repayment: a person or a stronger entity that agrees, in a separate signed contract, to answer for the loan.

The guaranty is a different document from the note and the mortgage, and it can be enforced on its own terms. That matters because the guarantor is usually not the party the loan was made to. The guarantor never receives the loan proceeds as a borrower; they receive the benefit of the deal as an owner and the burden of the guaranty as a separate obligor. For the business-lending version of the same idea, including limited and joint guarantees, see personal guarantee. This page covers the commercial real estate side: who the guarantor is, what the lender tests, and what ongoing obligations come with the signature.

Guarantor vs. Key Principal vs. sponsor

The words overlap, and lenders use them differently, so pin down which one a document means.

  • Guarantor is the legal role: the party that signs the guaranty. A guarantor can be an individual, a trust, or an entity with its own balance sheet.
  • Key Principal is the agency term. Fannie Mae's Multifamily Guide describes a Key Principal as a person who controls or manages the borrower or the property, is critical to operating them, or may be required to provide a guaranty. Freddie Mac uses Key Borrower Principal and defines it to include any guarantor, whatever their ownership interest and even if they do not appear in the borrower's ownership structure.
  • Sponsor is the market word for the person or group behind the deal, whose net worth, liquidity, and track record the lender is underwriting. In most files the sponsor and the guarantor are the same people. They do not have to be: an entity can guarantee, and a sponsor can be a general partner without signing.

One practical consequence: being named a Key Principal is not automatically the same as having signed a guaranty. The lender may require both a certification of your finances and a signature on the guaranty form. Read what you are being asked to sign.

What lenders test

A lender is underwriting the guarantor in addition to the property, and the questions are consistent across lender types:

  • Net worth. Total assets minus total liabilities, usually from a signed personal financial statement. Lenders discount assets that are illiquid, pledged elsewhere, or tied up in the deal being financed.
  • Liquidity. Cash and marketable securities that can be turned into cash quickly. Agency lenders verify it rather than accept a number on a form: Fannie Mae's guide calls for bank or brokerage statements covering three consecutive months, and a bank letter alone is not enough. Freddie Mac requires a Key Borrower Principal to verify liquidity equal to the lesser of what the guarantor reports and twice the minimum stated in the quote.
  • Contingent liabilities. Other guaranties you have signed. A guarantor with ten guaranties on ten loans is not as strong as the net worth statement suggests, and lenders add them up.
  • Credit. A credit report, plus a check for recent defaults, judgments, bankruptcy, or foreclosure.
  • Experience. Whether the guarantor has owned and managed this property type. A strong balance sheet without operating history is often paired with an experienced manager or a second guarantor.

None of these has one national minimum. Each lender sets its minimums, usually as a multiple of the loan or a dollar amount in the term sheet, and the numbers vary with property type and leverage. Ask for them in writing early.

Worked example

Take the loan used throughout this site: $1,400,000 against a $2,000,000 property. The loan-to-value ratio, run through our LTV calculator, is 70.0%, which leaves a $600,000 down payment.

Suppose the sponsor is two partners, each of whom will sign. The lender's quote, in this hypothetical, sets minimum post-closing liquidity at $140,000 and requires the guarantors to show it.

Partner APartner B
Reported liquid assets$900,000$95,000
Liquidity to verify (lesser of reported, or 2 × $140,000 = $280,000)$280,000$95,000
Covers the $140,000 minimum alone?YesNo

Partner A carries the liquidity test by themselves, even though their $900,000 is far above the cap, because the cap sets the amount to verify. Partner B's $95,000 helps only if the lender allows liquidity to be combined across guarantors. That is the first question to ask in a joint-venture deal, because it determines who has to be on the guaranty.

The same table also shows what the signature costs. If the guaranty is a full recourse guaranty and the property is eventually sold for less than the $1,400,000 owed, the lender can pursue Partner A for the shortfall, and Partner A's $900,000 is not protected by the LLC. If instead the loan is non-recourse with a carve-out guaranty, Partner A is exposed only if a listed act occurs. See bad boy carve-outs and springing recourse for which acts and how large the exposure becomes.

Guarantor vs. co-borrower

A co-borrower signs the note and owns the debt directly, with the property and its income in front of the lender. A guarantor signs a separate promise that is only called on if the borrower does not perform. The difference matters for how the lender can pursue you and what a release requires, so read which role the documents give you. Do not accept a co-borrower signature where the lender asked for a guaranty without understanding the change.

Which loans require which kind of guarantor

  • SBA 7(a) and 504. 13 CFR 120.160 generally requires holders of at least a 20% ownership interest to guarantee the loan, and allows SBA, or a lender with delegated authority, to require full or limited guaranties from other individuals or entities regardless of their ownership share. The guaranty is of repayment, not just carve-outs. See SBA 7(a) loans.
  • Agency multifamily (Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac). The loans are non-recourse to the property, backed by a guaranty from the Key Principal. Fannie Mae's guide requires a Non-Recourse Guaranty from a Key Principal when the underwritten DSCR is below 1.35 on a fixed-rate loan or 1.10 on a variable-rate loan, or when LTV is above 65%, and the guide lists exceptions such as a publicly traded Key Principal or a cooperative borrower. Thresholds in the guide change, so confirm them against the current text before you rely on them.
  • CMBS. Conduit loans are normally non-recourse, with a carve-out guaranty, and often a separate environmental indemnity, from the sponsor. See CMBS loans and CMBS loan.
  • Banks and credit unions. Portfolio lenders commonly want full recourse guaranties from every principal, sometimes limited to a percentage. The upside is more flexibility on release and terms. See permanent financing.
  • Bridge and construction. Short-term and construction lenders often ask for repayment guaranties, and construction adds completion and cost-overrun guaranties on top.

Why lenders care

On a non-recourse loan the property is the real collateral and the guarantor is the enforcement mechanism for everything the property cannot cover: misapplied rents, insurance proceeds that do not reach the building, unauthorized transfers. The lender underwrites the guarantor for two reasons. The first is practicality: a guaranty is only worth what its signer can pay. The second is behavior. A sponsor with real money outside the deal is less likely to walk away from a struggling asset, and a sponsor with experience is more likely to fix one. This is why a guarantor with great financials but no experience is often asked to add an experienced operator, and why one with experience but thin liquidity is often asked to add capital or a co-guarantor.

What comes after closing

The guaranty is not a one-time certification. Agency and bank loans commonly carry ongoing reporting covenants: annual financial statements, tax returns, and minimum net worth and liquidity tested on a schedule. The guaranty states the exact delivery dates. A guarantor who falls below a covenant, or who simply stops delivering statements, can be in default under the guaranty even if the loan itself is current.

That has a planning consequence. If you are pledging liquidity to satisfy a covenant, you cannot spend it on the next acquisition. Before you take on a second guaranty, work out whether the first one still tests.

How to limit your exposure

Guaranty terms are negotiable at the term sheet, and almost never afterward. The usual asks, in rough order of value:

  • Non-recourse with carve-outs instead of full recourse. When the deal and lender allow it, this changes the signature from a promise to repay into a promise not to misbehave.
  • Loss-only instead of full recourse for the minor triggers. Liability should match the lender's actual damages unless the act is serious.
  • Cure periods and materiality thresholds. A technical breach, such as a late financial statement, should not become a default without notice and time to fix it.
  • Burn-off. A dollar cap that falls, or a guaranty that ends, once the property reaches a stated DSCR or debt yield for a stated period. Ask for it when you sign, because a lender has no reason to offer it later.
  • Replacement and transfer rights. A written right to substitute a guarantor who meets the same financial tests, and to transfer ownership among existing owners and for estate planning without triggering a default. See loan assumption.
  • Several, not joint and several. If several partners guarantee, ask that each be liable only for a percentage, not for the whole amount. Lenders often refuse, but when partners have unequal balance sheets the strongest one pays for the others' share if the answer is no.

What to watch for

  • A guaranty signed in a trust or entity name. It can look like personal protection and still not be. Ask counsel what assets stand behind the signature.
  • Financial covenants that outlast the use of the money. A minimum-liquidity requirement can sit on your balance sheet for the entire term, including through a downturn.
  • Cross-default. Some guaranties let a default on one of your other loans trigger a default on this one.
  • Estates and divorce. A guarantor's death, incapacity, or divorce can be defined as a default or require a replacement guarantor on a deadline. Ask what the document says now.
  • Survival. Carve-out liability typically survives foreclosure and deed in lieu. Handing back the property does not necessarily end the guaranty.

If you want a second read on a guaranty before you sign, start an application and attach the term sheet. For the broader choice between guaranteeing repayment and signing a carve-out guaranty, see recourse vs. non-recourse loans. For business loans, see personal guarantees on business loans.

Sources: Fannie Mae Multifamily Selling and Servicing Guide (Key Principals, Principals, and Guarantors; Net Worth and Liquid Assets; Non-Recourse Guaranty), mfguide.fanniemae.com. Freddie Mac Multifamily Seller/Servicer Guide, mf.freddiemac.com (Key Borrower Principal; liquidity). 13 CFR § 120.160 (SBA guaranty requirements). Examples are illustrations, not quotes; each lender sets its own minimums.

Frequently asked

What is a guarantor on a commercial real estate loan?

A guarantor is a person or entity, separate from the borrowing LLC, that signs a guaranty promising to answer for the loan if the borrower does not. On a recourse loan the guaranty covers repayment of the debt. On a non-recourse loan it is usually a carve-out guaranty that makes the guarantor liable only for listed bad acts, with the most serious ones making the whole loan recourse.

What is a Key Principal?

Key Principal is the agency lending term for the person who controls or manages the borrower or the property, is critical to operating it, or may be required to provide the guaranty. Fannie Mae uses the term, and Freddie Mac uses Key Borrower Principal, defined to include any guarantor whatever their ownership share. The lender underwrites that person's finances and experience along with the property.

Does every owner have to be a guarantor?

Not always. SBA rules generally require anyone owning 20% or more of the applicant to guarantee the loan, and allow SBA or the lender to require guaranties from others at any ownership level. Conventional and agency lenders choose guarantors by financial strength and control instead of a fixed percentage, so a small owner may be asked to sign while a larger passive one is not.

How much net worth and liquidity must a guarantor have?

There is no single number. Each lender sets minimums in the term sheet or quote, and they vary with loan size, property type, and leverage. Agency lenders verify liquidity with bank or brokerage statements, and Agency and bank lenders can require the guarantor to certify net worth and liquid assets on a schedule. Get the dollar figures in writing at the term sheet stage, before you spend money on third-party reports.

Can a guarantor be released or replaced?

Sometimes, but only with the lender's consent, and a replacement guarantor normally has to meet the lender's financial tests. Releases are usually negotiated at closing as burn-off triggers, or arise through a sale and loan assumption in which the buyer provides a new guaranty. Asking later, without a contract right, gives the lender no reason to say yes.

Related terms