Commercial Real Estate Legal

Springing Recourse

Springing Recourse, in short

Springing recourse means a loan that is non-recourse on the day you close can become fully recourse later. If you trip a listed trigger, usually a voluntary bankruptcy, an unapproved transfer, unauthorized extra debt, or a breach of single-purpose-entity rules, the guarantor becomes personally liable for the whole loan balance, not only the lender's actual loss.

Also called springing guarantyspringing liabilityfull recourse carve-outspringing recourse guaranty

How springing recourse works

A non-recourse loan limits the lender to the property if the loan goes bad. Springing recourse is the exception that sits behind that promise. The guaranty is dormant while the loan performs and while you stay inside the rules. If a listed event occurs, it springs to life and the guarantor becomes personally responsible for the debt.

The word that matters is full. Most carve-out lists have two tiers. In the first, you owe the lender's actual loss from a specific act. In the second, the springing tier, you owe the whole unpaid balance, plus enforcement costs, whether or not your act caused any loss. This page is about that second tier. The full list of acts, including the loss-only ones, is on our page for bad boy carve-outs.

Guarantor exposure after a springing trigger = unpaid loan balance + accrued interest and fees + enforcement costs − net foreclosure proceeds already applied

In practice, lenders sue on a deficiency after the property is sold. The springing clause matters most at exactly that moment: it decides whether the deficiency is the lender's loss or yours.

Worked example

An investor buys a property for $2,000,000 with a $1,400,000 non-recourse loan (70% of price). Several years later the property is sold at foreclosure for $1,150,000. For simplicity, assume the unpaid balance is the original $1,400,000 and ignore accrued interest and costs. The deficiency is $250,000.

ScenarioWhat happenedGuarantor owes
No triggerMarket declined, property performed until it could not$0 — the lender absorbs the $250,000
Loss-only carve-out$60,000 of rent was spent on another project while taxes went unpaidAbout $60,000 — the lender’s loss from that act
Springing triggerThe borrower filed a voluntary bankruptcy to stop the foreclosureThe full $250,000 deficiency, plus enforcement costs

Notice what the third row does not say. The bankruptcy filing did not cost the lender $250,000. The deficiency came from the property’s value. The springing clause simply says that once you cross that line, the lender is no longer limited to the property, and the loss that was supposed to be the lender’s becomes yours.

Now scale the same structure to a larger loan. On the $8,700,000 CMBS loan in the case discussed below, the deficiency the lender pursued was about $2.1 million. That is the size of exposure a guarantor can face when a springing clause is enforced.

The usual triggers

Lists vary by lender, but the springing tier is built around a short set of events:

  • Voluntary bankruptcy. The borrower files, or colludes in an involuntary petition. This is the classic trigger and the reason a restructuring plan should be reviewed against the guaranty before anyone files anything.
  • Unapproved transfer. Selling the property, or transferring a controlling interest in the borrowing entity, without written consent. Many documents treat estate-planning transfers, partner buyouts, and a change in the controlling owner the same way unless they are carved out. A negotiated loan assumption with consent is the safe route.
  • Unauthorized additional debt. A second mortgage, mezzanine loan, or other lien not approved by the lender. See stack position for how these layers rank.
  • Single-purpose-entity breaches. Non-recourse pricing assumes the borrower owns one property and nothing else. Commingling funds or taking on other business can breach that, and some lenders make the breach itself a full-recourse event.
  • Fraud or material misrepresentation. Agency multifamily documents are a well-known example. Fannie Mae’s loan agreement makes the borrower and guarantors liable for the entire debt on certain violations, including failing the single-asset requirements and fraud or material misrepresentation in underwriting or ongoing reporting.
  • Solvency or insolvency covenants. Rarer, and controversial, as the next section shows.

The Cherryland case: when insolvency became the trigger

The best-known springing recourse dispute is Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. Cherryland Mall Limited Partnership. The borrower had an $8.7 million CMBS loan on a mall, and the guarantor signed a guaranty. The lender bid $6 million at foreclosure and sued for the roughly $2.1 million deficiency.

The loan documents required the borrower to remain solvent as part of its single-purpose-entity covenants, and they made a breach a full-recourse event. On December 27, 2011, the Michigan Court of Appeals held that the borrower’s failure to remain solvent triggered full recourse, because the documents said any failure to remain solvent, no matter the cause, was a violation.

The reaction was fast. Michigan enacted the Nonrecourse Mortgage Loan Act in 2012 (Act 67 of 2012, signed March 29, 2012). It defines a “post-closing solvency covenant” and provides that such a covenant may not be used, directly or indirectly, as a nonrecourse carve-out. In April 2013, applying the Act, the Michigan Court of Appeals decided Cherryland the opposite way and upheld the Act’s constitutionality.

Two lessons follow. First, springing triggers are enforced as written, which is why the drafting matters. Second, the rules differ by state. A solvency trigger that Michigan now blocks can still appear in loan documents governed by another state’s law, so read the language even if you have heard the clause is “unenforceable.”

TermWhat it meansHow it differs
Full recourse loanThe guarantor is liable for the debt from day oneSpringing recourse is conditional; full recourse is not
Loss-only carve-outLiability limited to the lender’s actual damages from an actSpringing recourse covers the whole balance
Personal guaranteeA guaranty of repayment, usually on small business and bank loansSpringing recourse guarantees conduct that triggers repayment
Partial or burn-off recourseA fixed portion of the loan is guaranteed, often falling away as performance improvesSpringing recourse has no cap once triggered

For the wider comparison of loan structures, see our article on recourse vs. non-recourse loans.

Why lenders care

A lender in a non-recourse deal cannot lean on your personal balance sheet, so it controls behavior instead. Springing triggers cover the actions that most damage its position in a workout: a bankruptcy filing delays foreclosure, an unapproved transfer changes who the lender is dealing with, and extra debt adds a competing creditor. The harshness is the point. The clause is meant to make the sponsor choose the cooperative path when the deal is under stress.

This is also why springing recourse is built into CMBS and agency loans. CMBS loans are pooled and sold to investors, and the servicer works under the pooling and servicing agreement, which limits how much it can bend the documents after closing. Agency loans are standardized in a similar way. Either way, the time to negotiate is before closing.

What to watch for and how to negotiate

  • Ask which tier each item sits in. Have counsel mark the guaranty: loss-only on one side, full recourse on the other. Try to move items from the springing tier to the loss-only tier.
  • Narrow the bankruptcy trigger. Push for the filing to count only when the borrower files voluntarily or colludes, and not when an unaffiliated creditor files and you contest it in good faith.
  • Add cure periods and materiality. A transfer or lien trigger with a 30-day cure is far safer than one with none. Ask for the cure in writing.
  • Carve out ordinary transfers. Request permission for transfers among existing owners, to family trusts for estate planning, and on death or incapacity.
  • Resist insolvency triggers. A clause that springs because the borrower is short of cash turns a market downturn into personal liability. Where state law does not already prohibit it, push to remove it.
  • Check the guarantor covenants. Many guaranties require the guarantor to keep a minimum net worth and liquidity, and some let you substitute a replacement guarantor. Ask what happens if the guarantor no longer qualifies.
  • Understand the survival period. Springing liability can outlive the property. Handing back the keys, or a deed in lieu, does not necessarily end it.
  • Ask before you act. Consent requests are a normal part of servicing, and asking first is the safer path. Acting first and asking later is how paperwork becomes personal liability. If you are heading toward a default or a modification, talk to counsel before talking to the servicer.

What it means for your financing

Springing recourse is not a reason to avoid non-recourse debt. For many sponsors, the ability to keep a bad outcome on one property is worth the conditions. It is a reason to read the guaranty, not just the term sheet, and to compare the tradeoffs on your specific deal. Compare structures such as permanent financing and CMBS loans on the guaranty language as well as the rate and proceeds.

If you want a deal reviewed with the carve-out structure in mind, start an application and include the term sheet.

Sources: Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. Cherryland Mall Ltd. Partnership (Mich. Ct. App. Dec. 27, 2011, and Apr. 9, 2013 decision on remand); Michigan Nonrecourse Mortgage Loan Act, Act 67 of 2012 (MCL 445.1591 et seq.); Fannie Mae Multifamily Loan and Security Agreement forms and Multifamily Selling and Servicing Guide. The worked example uses illustrative figures and ignores interest and costs.

Frequently asked

What is springing recourse in a commercial real estate loan?

It is a provision that lets a lender treat a non-recourse loan as full recourse if the borrower or guarantor triggers a named event. Common triggers are a voluntary bankruptcy filing, a transfer of the property or a controlling ownership interest without consent, unauthorized subordinate debt, and breaches of single-purpose-entity covenants. The guarantor then becomes liable for the full debt rather than only the lender's loss.

What is the difference between springing recourse and bad boy carve-outs?

Bad boy carve-outs are the whole list of acts that create personal liability. Springing recourse is the severe tier of that list: the triggers that make the guarantor liable for the entire loan balance. The milder tier, often called loss carve-outs, limits liability to the lender's actual damages from the act.

Can a solvency covenant trigger springing recourse?

It can, depending on state law. In Wells Fargo Bank v. Cherryland Mall (Mich. Ct. App., December 27, 2011), a borrower's failure to stay solvent breached its single-purpose-entity covenant and triggered full recourse on an $8.7 million CMBS loan. Michigan then passed the Nonrecourse Mortgage Loan Act in 2012, which bars post-closing solvency covenants from being used as a carve-out. The statute is Michigan's, so in other states the covenant language still matters and should be checked with counsel.

Does springing recourse apply to every non-recourse loan?

Most commercial non-recourse loans have some version of it. CMBS and agency multifamily loans typically pair non-recourse debt with a guaranty of this kind. The specific triggers, cure periods, and whether liability is full or loss-only vary by lender and are negotiable before closing.

How do you avoid triggering springing recourse?

Get the trigger list in writing before closing, run property income through the property, never take on other debt or transfer ownership interests without written consent, keep the borrower a true single-purpose entity, and have bankruptcy counsel read the guaranty before any restructuring step. Most triggers are avoided by asking permission first.

Articles that use this term

Related terms