Commercial Real Estate Basics

Preferred Equity

Preferred Equity, in short

Preferred equity is capital invested in the entity that owns a property, repaid after the senior loan but before the common owners, with a priority return that is usually fixed. It is not secured by the building. If payments are missed, the investor's remedies come from the operating agreement, often including the right to take control.

Also called pref equitypreferred equity investmentprefpreferred return equity

How preferred equity works

A property is often bought or recapitalized with more money than a senior lender will advance and more than the sponsor wants to put in. Preferred equity is one way to fill that gap. The investor puts cash into the entity that owns the property, usually an LLC or limited partnership, and in return receives a preferred return: a priority claim on cash flow and sale proceeds that must be satisfied before the common owners receive a distribution.

Fannie Mae's Multifamily Guide defines it broadly as a direct or indirect investment in the borrower for which the governing document gives the investor an asset management fee or any other fee before returns are paid to the investors, or preferred or unequal rights to receive returns compared with the other equity investors. The common version in practice looks like this:

  • The investor contributes a fixed amount, for example $3,000,000.
  • The operating agreement promises a preferred return, for example 12% a year, either paid currently from cash flow or accrued and paid at a sale or refinance.
  • The investor is repaid its capital and any unpaid preferred return before the common owners get a dollar of profit.
  • If the sponsor misses payments or breaks the agreement, the investor gets remedies: a higher return, removal of the manager, or the right to take control of the entity.
Attachment point = senior debt ÷ value; detachment point = (senior debt + preferred equity) ÷ value

In the example below, the preferred layer attaches at 65% of value and detaches at 80%.

Because it is equity, it is not recorded as a mortgage or a lien on the real estate. That is the feature that makes it attractive when the senior loan documents prohibit a second mortgage, and the feature that makes it harder to enforce than a loan. For the full ordering of every layer, see capital stack.

Worked example: a $3,000,000 preferred layer

These are illustrative assumptions, the same ones used in our capital stack example, with the junior layer changed from a loan to preferred equity: a $20,000,000 purchase producing $1,400,000 of net operating income, a $13,000,000 senior loan at 6.5% interest-only, $3,000,000 of preferred equity at a 12% preferred return paid currently, and $4,000,000 of common equity. Fees and closing costs are ignored.

LayerAmountShare of $20MReturnAnnual payment
Senior debt$13,000,00065%6.5% interest$845,000
Preferred equity$3,000,00015%12% preferred return$360,000
Common equity$4,000,00020%residual$195,000
Total$20,000,000100%$1,400,000 of NOI

NOI of $1,400,000 pays $845,000 to the senior lender and leaves $555,000. The preferred return takes $360,000 of that, which leaves $195,000 for the common owners — a 4.9% cash yield on their $4,000,000. The senior loan alone is covered 1.66 times, but with the preferred payment counted as a fixed charge the property covers its priority payments only 1.16 times ($1,400,000 ÷ $1,205,000). The senior lender sees a 65% loan-to-value and a 10.77% debt yield; a lender that counts the preferred layer sees 80% combined leverage and an 8.75% debt yield, because $16,000,000 now sits ahead of the common owners. Run your own numbers through the debt yield calculator and the LTV calculator; both reproduce these figures.

Current pay versus accrual

Now suppose the investor accrues the 12% instead of being paid monthly, compounding annually, and the property is sold after three years. The preferred balance grows from $3,000,000 to $3,360,000, then $3,763,200, then $4,214,784. Proceeds go to the senior loan first, then the preferred investor's balance, then the common owners (interest, fees and selling costs ignored):

Sale priceSenior ($13M)Preferred ($4,214,784 owed)Common
$22,000,000$13,000,000$4,214,784$4,785,216
$20,000,000$13,000,000$4,214,784$2,785,216
$18,000,000$13,000,000$4,214,784$785,216
$16,000,000$13,000,000$3,000,000 (short by $1,214,784)$0

With accrual the sponsor receives all the operating cash flow, but a $20,000,000 sale — no loss against the purchase price — returns only $2,785,216 to the common owners at the sale. Add the $1,665,000 of operating cash flow they kept over three years ($555,000 a year) and they receive about $4,450,000 in total on $4,000,000 invested; the compounding preferred balance is what keeps that figure from being higher. If the same investor had been paid currently and received only its $3,000,000 back at sale, the common owners would have received $4,000,000 at a $20,000,000 sale, but the investor would have been paid $360,000 a year out of cash flow along the way, which is why the sponsor's yearly distribution was $195,000 instead of $555,000. Accrual is the costlier structure. Current pay returns $1,080,000 of preferred return over three years plus the $3,000,000 of capital, $4,080,000 in all; accrual with annual compounding owes $4,214,784, which is $134,784 more, because the unpaid return itself earns the return. At $16,000,000 the common owners lose everything in both cases, and in the accrual case the preferred investor is not made whole either.

Types and structures

  • Current-pay (hard-pay) preferred equity. The return is paid monthly or quarterly from cash flow, and missing a payment triggers remedies, often a control takeover. Agency lenders treat this as debt-like: Fannie Mae's guide calls it hard-pay preferred equity, counts it in combined loan-to-value, and includes its required payments in DSCR. Check the current guide for the limits that apply, because they change.
  • Soft-pay preferred equity. The preferred return is paid only from available cash flow, with the unpaid amount accruing. Agency lenders treat the three structures differently, so a soft-pay layer is usually reviewed under lighter terms than a layer with mandatory payments.
  • Mandatory-pay preferred equity. The sponsor must pay the return on a schedule regardless of cash flow, and the investor's remedy is typically a forced sale. Fannie Mae's guide names it as a separate structure with its own underwriting requirements.
  • Participating preferred equity. The investor receives the preferred return plus a share of profit at a sale or refinance. That participation pushes the real cost above the stated rate, so ask for it in writing when you compare offers.

Those labels are the agency vocabulary; private preferred equity funds use their own names, so compare what the operating agreement says rather than the label.

Preferred equity vs. mezzanine debt vs. common equity

Mezzanine debt, preferred equity and common equity all sit below the senior loan. The differences decide who can do what after a problem.

Mezzanine debtPreferred equityCommon equity
What it isA loanAn ownership interest with priorityAn ownership interest, last in line
SecurityPledge of the entity's ownership interestsNone; contract rights in the operating agreementNone
EnforcementUCC sale of the pledged interestsRemoval of the manager, control, forced saleResidual only
ReturnInterest, 11–16%Preferred return, roughly 10–18% per our mezzanine comparisonNo promise; 20–30%+ IRR targets

Our mezzanine financing page compares all three for a deal, including the combined leverage of 75–90% combined that a mezzanine structure typically reaches. Mezzanine lenders enforce under Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code, which requires every aspect of a sale to be commercially reasonable (UCC 9-610) and reasonable notice before it (UCC 9-611). A preferred investor has no statute behind it; the remedy exists only to the extent the operating agreement grants it. That is why preferred equity agreements are negotiated in detail, and why a senior lender reads them closely.

Preferred equity is also not the same as a senior loan, which holds the first lien and is repaid first, or a second mortgage, which is a loan secured by the same property behind the first. And it is not "preferred stock" in the public-company sense: the investor owns an interest in a private entity with no market to sell it.

Why lenders care

A senior lender underwrites everything ahead of the sponsor's cash, because the preferred layer thins the cushion beneath the senior loan and adds a party with the right to take control.

  • It is counted in leverage. Fannie Mae's guide adds hard-pay preferred equity to the mortgage when it calculates combined LTV, and includes the required payments in DSCR. Expect a senior lender to size on combined numbers, not the first loan alone.
  • It usually needs consent. Freddie Mac generally does not permit subordinate financing on newly originated mortgages without approval. Bank and CMBS loan documents commonly restrict changes in ownership and control too.
  • A control takeover is a change of principals. Fannie Mae's guide requires a preferred investor with control rights to be underwritten as a principal in some structures. Either way, a senior lender wants to know in advance who could end up in control.
  • The preferred layer has its own maturity. A preferred return that accrues and a redemption date that falls before stabilization is a refinance risk. See the maturity wall and your senior maturity date.

What to watch for and how to negotiate

  • Get the senior lender's position first. A preferred layer the senior lender will not allow is not an option. Ask before you spend on legal fees.
  • Define "default" narrowly. Many preferred terms treat a missed payment, a covenant breach, or a failed coverage test as a trigger. Ask for notice and cure periods and for triggers that depend on facts you control.
  • Understand what a takeover costs. If the investor can remove you as manager, find out whether you lose the asset, the management fee, the promote, or all three, and whether a guaranty is involved. Some carve-outs mirror bad boy carve-outs on the senior loan.
  • Compare the all-in cost. Add the preferred return, any minimum multiple, participation, origination and exit fees, and any redemption premium. Compare the result with the blended cost of the whole stack, the way the example above does.
  • Set the redemption path. Decide how and when the preferred layer is repaid: a sale, a refinance, or a buyout. Check for prepayment premiums and a minimum equity multiple that make an early exit costly.
  • Stress the common equity. Run the waterfall at 10% and 20% lower sale prices, as in the table above. Your return is what is left after two priority claims.
  • Look at the alternative. A lower-cost way to reduce your cash may be a different senior structure, such as a lower-rate permanent loan or a bridge loan that closes the gap until the property stabilizes.

To see how much the senior layer will carry before you decide whether you need anything below it, start a commercial real estate loan application, and compare the layers with the internal rate of return you expect on the equity you keep.

Sources: Fannie Mae Multifamily Guide, “Mezzanine Financing; Preferred Equity and Structured Common Equity,” “Preferred Equity,” and “Calculating the DSCR and LTV” (mfguide.fanniemae.com). Freddie Mac Multifamily Seller/Servicer Guide, subordinate financing provisions (mf.freddiemac.com); Uniform Commercial Code Article 9, §§ 9-610 and 9-611 (law.cornell.edu/ucc/9). Example figures are illustrative assumptions and ignore fees, taxes and selling costs, and treat the preferred balance as compounding once a year; rates and returns are example ranges, not quotes.

Frequently asked

What is preferred equity in real estate?

It is an ownership investment in the borrowing entity that is paid a priority return before the common owners receive anything. It sits below the senior loan and above common equity in the capital stack. It is not secured by a lien on the property, so the investor's rights come from the operating agreement rather than a mortgage.

How is preferred equity different from mezzanine debt?

Mezzanine debt is a loan secured by a pledge of the entity's ownership interests, and after a default the lender can enforce through a Uniform Commercial Code sale of those interests. Preferred equity is an ownership interest with a priority return, and its remedies are whatever the operating agreement says: usually removing the manager, taking control, or forcing a sale.

Does preferred equity count toward leverage?

Lenders usually count it. Fannie Mae's Multifamily Guide, for example, adds hard-pay preferred equity to the mortgage when it calculates combined loan-to-value, and includes required mezzanine or hard-pay preferred payments in the DSCR. Treat the preferred layer as debt when you estimate how much the senior lender will fund.

Does the senior lender have to approve preferred equity?

Often. Senior loan documents restrict transfers of ownership interests and changes of control, and a preferred investor's takeover right can be exactly that. Freddie Mac, for example, generally does not permit subordinate financing on newly originated mortgages without its approval. Read the senior term sheet before you approach a preferred equity source.

What return do preferred equity investors expect?

Our mezzanine page compares preferred equity at roughly 10–18% preferred return, which sits between senior debt and the 20–30%+ IRR targets quoted for joint-venture equity. The actual number depends on how high in leverage the investment attaches, the asset, the sponsor and whether the return is paid currently or accrues. These are example ranges, not quotes.

Related terms