Senior Debt
Senior Debt, in short
Senior debt is the first-lien loan on a property. If the borrower defaults, the senior lender forecloses and is repaid first, ahead of any second mortgage, mezzanine lender or equity investor. Because it takes the least risk, it carries the lowest rate and the strictest terms, and it is the layer every other lender in the deal has to work around.
Also called senior loanfirst mortgagefirst lien loansenior secured debtfirst position loan
How senior debt works
Every loan secured by a property ranks against every other claim on that property. Senior debt is the claim that ranks first. The lender records a mortgage or deed of trust against the property, and under the usual rule of "first in time, first in right," that early recording is what puts it at the front of the line. The date of recording in the county property records is what sets priority among most liens. Property tax liens and some other statutory liens can rank ahead regardless of recording date, and state law governs the details.
That position is the entire point. If the borrower stops paying, the senior lender can foreclose, sell the property, and collect its principal, interest and costs from the proceeds before anyone else is paid. Whatever is left goes to the next claim in line. In the capital stack, that makes senior debt the top layer: the first to be repaid, the last to lose money, and the cheapest money in the deal.
Senior loan amount = the lowest of (value × maximum LTV), (NOI ÷ required DSCR ÷ loan constant) and (NOI ÷ minimum debt yield)
Most single-property deals use only senior debt and the buyer's own equity. A buyer who puts $600,000 into a $2,000,000 purchase and borrows $1,400,000 has a two-layer stack: a 70% senior loan and 30% equity. The senior loan is the whole debt side of the deal.
Senior vs. subordinate debt, and what "secured" means
Lenders describe everything behind the senior loan as subordinate or junior debt. Subordination can come from recording order or from a written subordination agreement, in which a lender agrees to rank behind another. When two lenders share the same first position, they may rank pari passu, meaning equally, and a single first mortgage is sometimes split into an A-note and a B-note with the A-note paid first. In business lending, "senior secured" means the debt ranks first and is backed by specific collateral, while "senior unsecured" means it ranks ahead of other unsecured debt but has no collateral pledged. A commercial mortgage is senior secured debt: the property is the collateral.
Advantages and drawbacks
- Lowest cost. The first-lien position is the least risky, so the rate is the lowest in the stack.
- Largest single layer. It usually funds most of the purchase price, which reduces the equity you must bring.
- Strict terms. Senior lenders set the tightest covenants, reserves, reporting and limits on additional debt.
- Limited leverage. Its LTV, DSCR and debt yield limits cap how much it will lend, which is why some deals add junior capital.
How a senior lender sizes the loan
A senior lender sets the loan amount by running the property through several tests and taking the smallest answer. Loan-to-value caps the loan as a share of what the property is worth. Debt service coverage requires the property's income to cover the payment by a margin. Debt yield compares income to the loan balance with no interest rate in it at all, which is why lenders use it as a cross-check on the other two.
Take the example property with $160,000 of NOI. At 70% LTV the loan is $1,400,000. At the same 6.5%, 25-year terms, that loan passes a DSCR test with room to spare at 1.41x. If a lender instead insisted on a 12% debt yield, the maximum loan would be $160,000 ÷ 12% = $1,333,333, and that tighter test would set the loan, not the 70% LTV. Which test binds changes with the interest rate, the property type and the lender, so the same building can support different senior loans from different sources. Our max loan calculator shows how the limits interact.
Who provides senior debt
Senior debt is a position, not a product. Many types of lenders can hold it, and they differ in price, leverage, speed and recourse.
- Banks and credit unions. The most common source for owner-occupied and smaller investment property. On our terms, bank CRE runs 65–75% (80% multifamily) LTV over a 5–10 yr term, at an example range of 6.5–8%.
- Agencies. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac finance multifamily; see agency loans.
- CMBS and life companies. Larger, stabilized properties, often with non-recourse structures. See CMBS loans and our CMBS page.
- Bridge and construction lenders. Short-term first liens on properties in transition. A bridge loan is senior debt for 12–36 mo, sized at 65–80%.
- SBA programs. In an SBA 504 deal, the bank holds the first lien on the property and the CDC's portion sits behind it, so the bank loan is the senior debt. See SBA 504 loans.
For a full look at the permanent version, see permanent financing, which runs 75–80% loan-to-value over 5–30 yr.
Worked example: a $1,400,000 senior loan
These are illustrative assumptions, not a quote. A buyer purchases a property for $2,000,000 and borrows $1,400,000 from a bank at an example rate of 6.5%, with a 25-year amortization and a 10-year term. The property produces $160,000 of net operating income. We ran the loan through the same math as our commercial mortgage calculator and DSCR calculator.
| Measure | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Loan-to-value | $1,400,000 ÷ $2,000,000 | 70% |
| Monthly payment | 6.5%, 25-year amortization | $9,453 |
| Annual debt service | $9,453 × 12 | $113,435 |
| Debt service coverage | $160,000 ÷ $113,435 | 1.41x |
| Debt yield | $160,000 ÷ $1,400,000 | 11.4% |
| Balance at the end of year 5 | amortization schedule | $1,267,870 |
| Balloon at maturity (year 10) | amortization schedule | $1,085,159 |
A senior lender looks at three of these numbers at once: LTV, DSCR and debt yield. A loan has to pass every test the lender applies, and the tightest test sets the maximum. Because the loan amortizes over 25 years but matures in 10, a balloon of $1,085,159 comes due at the maturity date. The difference between the term and the amortization is covered in loan term vs. amortization.
Who gets paid if the property sells for less
Now suppose the borrower later adds a $200,000 second mortgage, and the property is foreclosed. In this simple example, ignore costs and unpaid interest and say the senior balance is the full $1,400,000. Proceeds go to the senior lien first, then the second lien, then the owner.
| Sale price | Senior ($1,400,000) | Second lien ($200,000) | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| $1,800,000 | $1,400,000 | $200,000 | $200,000 |
| $1,600,000 | $1,400,000 | $200,000 | $0 |
| $1,500,000 | $1,400,000 | $100,000 (−50%) | $0 |
| $1,400,000 | $1,400,000 | $0 | $0 |
| $1,200,000 | $1,200,000 (−$200,000) | $0 | $0 |
The senior lender is made whole as long as the sale price stays at or above $1,400,000, which is a 30% drop from the $2,000,000 purchase price. The second lender is wiped out at $1,400,000. That cushion is why senior debt costs less than anything below it.
Senior debt vs. related terms
- Senior debt vs. mezzanine debt. Both are debt, but mezzanine is not secured by the real estate. It is secured by a pledge of the ownership interests in the borrowing entity, so after a default the mezzanine lender enforces against those interests instead of foreclosing on the building. See mezzanine financing.
- Senior debt vs. a second lien. A second lien is secured by the same property but sits behind the first. A senior foreclosure generally extinguishes it.
- Senior debt vs. preferred equity. Preferred equity is an ownership investment with a priority return, not a mortgage. It is paid after the senior loan.
- Senior debt vs. recourse. "Senior" describes priority; "recourse" describes whether the borrower or a guarantor is personally liable. A first mortgage can be recourse or non-recourse. See non-recourse loans and our article on recourse vs. non-recourse loans.
Why lenders care about the rest of the stack
A senior lender is not only underwriting the property. It also underwrites who else has a claim on it, because that determines how a problem loan plays out.
- Combined debt is counted. Fannie Mae's Multifamily Guide, for example, calculates LTV by adding the mortgage loan, any pre-existing mortgage loans, hard-pay preferred equity and any mezzanine financing, then dividing by the property value. It calculates DSCR with the required mezzanine or hard-pay preferred payments included in the debt service. Junior capital behind a senior loan can reduce what the senior lender will fund.
- Junior capital often needs consent. Senior loan documents commonly restrict additional liens, transfers of ownership interests and pledges of equity. A mezzanine lender normally signs an intercreditor agreement that sets cure rights and the conditions for taking control after a default.
- Collateral is recorded. The mortgage is recorded in the county records. Lenders also file a UCC financing statement on equipment, inventory and other personal property (fixture filings go in the county records), which date-stamps their priority in that collateral too.
- Cash controls. Senior lenders commonly collect tax and insurance reserves, covered in escrow and impounds, and may require a personal guarantee or carve-out guaranties such as bad-boy carve-outs and springing recourse.
What to watch for as a borrower
- Read the restrictions on junior debt before you need it. A senior loan that bans second liens and equity pledges for its whole term removes an option you may want later.
- Know which test sets your loan amount. If debt yield is the binding limit, a lower rate will not raise your proceeds. Test each one with the LTV and debt yield calculators.
- Check the prepayment terms. A senior loan is the one you are most likely to refinance, and a prepayment penalty can change the math of an early payoff.
- Plan for the balloon. In the example above, $1,085,159 is due at year 10. Confirm you have a refinance path before the maturity date arrives.
- Match the loan to the plan. A short bridge loan, a permanent mortgage and an SBA first lien have different terms and exits. Choose the senior debt that fits how long you will hold and what you will do with the property.
- Understand your personal exposure. Priority tells you who is paid first from the property, not whether you are personally liable for a shortfall.
Where senior debt fits in your plan
Start with the senior loan. It sets the base of the deal: how much cash you need, what the payment is, and whether anything below it is necessary at all. For most buyers, a single senior loan and their own equity is the simplest structure, and the cheapest.
If you are comparing options, start a commercial real estate loan application and we will show you the senior loan paths for your property first. To see how lenders size a first mortgage against value, read loan-to-value ratio explained.
Sources: Fannie Mae Multifamily Selling and Servicing Guide, “Calculating the DSCR and LTV” and “Mezzanine Financing” (mfguide.fanniemae.com); Uniform Commercial Code Article 9 (law.cornell.edu/ucc/9) on perfection by filing; 13 CFR Part 120, Subpart H (SBA 504 lien structure); general lien-priority and foreclosure rules (state law governs). Example figures are illustrative assumptions computed with the BestLoanUSA calculators and ignore fees, closing costs and unpaid interest; rates are example ranges, not quotes.
Frequently asked
What is senior debt in real estate?
It is the loan secured by a first lien on the property. If the borrower defaults, the senior lender can foreclose and is paid from the sale proceeds before any second mortgage holder, mezzanine lender or equity investor. Most conventional commercial mortgages are senior debt.
Is a first mortgage the same as senior debt?
In practice, yes. "First mortgage," "first lien loan" and "senior loan" describe the same position: the lien recorded first on the property. "Senior debt" is the term used when you are comparing that loan to the other layers in the capital stack.
Why does senior debt have the lowest interest rate?
Because it is the last layer to lose money. The property would have to sell for less than the senior balance before the senior lender takes a loss, and the lender holds a recorded lien it can enforce. Lenders price that protection in, so each layer below the senior loan costs more.
What happens to junior debt when the senior lender forecloses?
A foreclosure by the senior lienholder generally wipes out the junior liens recorded behind it. Proceeds go first to the foreclosing lender, then to junior lienholders in order of priority, and anything left over goes to the owner. A junior lender whose lien is wiped out may still have a claim against the borrower personally, depending on the documents and state law.
How much of a property's price does senior debt usually cover?
It depends on the lender and the property type. On our bank CRE terms, the loan-to-value runs 65–75% (80% multifamily), and permanent financing runs 75–80%. Your actual amount is set by the lowest of the lender's LTV, debt service coverage and debt yield limits.
Can you have senior debt and still add mezzanine or preferred equity?
Sometimes. Many senior loan documents restrict additional liens, transfers of ownership interests and pledges of equity, so the senior lender's consent is usually required, and a mezzanine lender generally signs an intercreditor agreement with it. Read the senior term sheet for these limits before you look for junior capital.