Commercial Real Estate Legal

Intercreditor Agreement

Intercreditor Agreement, in short

An intercreditor agreement is a contract between a senior lender and a junior lender, such as a mezzanine or second-lien lender, on the same deal. It sets payment priority, the junior lender's cure and purchase rights, how long each must wait before enforcing, and which changes need consent. Borrowers rarely sign but live with its terms.

Also called ICAintercreditormezzanine intercreditor agreementA/B intercreditor agreement

How an intercreditor agreement works

Every lender on a deal wants to be repaid first. When there is only one lender, that is simple. When a project carries a first mortgage and a mezzanine loan, or a first mortgage and a second lien, two lenders have claims on the same cash flow and the same collateral, and their interests collide the moment the borrower is late. An intercreditor agreement (ICA) is the contract the two lenders sign so that collision is settled in advance, in writing, rather than in a courtroom.

The senior lender writes most of the rules, because it can refuse to allow the junior loan at all. Many senior loan documents restrict additional liens and pledges of ownership interests, so the junior lender needs the senior lender's consent, and the ICA is the form that consent takes. See senior debt for why senior lenders restrict what sits beneath them. The agreement answers the same handful of questions on almost every deal:

  1. Who gets paid first? Cash from the property goes to the senior loan before it reaches the junior one, and if a sale or foreclosure produces less than the total debt, the senior lender is repaid in full first.
  2. What may the junior lender do after a default, and when? Usually nothing for a stated period, and then only certain things.
  3. Can the junior lender protect itself? Through cure rights and an option to buy the senior loan.
  4. What may the borrower and senior lender change without asking the junior lender? Modifications, extensions and additional advances are limited.
  5. Who may end up owning the borrower? Transfer of the mezzanine loan or of the pledged equity is limited to approved buyers.

The borrower is usually not a negotiating party, but it lives with the result. Every right the junior lender gains in the ICA is a right that can change how the senior lender treats you in a default, and every restriction on the senior lender is a limit on how quickly a workout can move.

The key provisions

Payment priority and subordination

For a second lien, the ICA or subordination agreement confirms that the junior lien is ranked behind the senior lien. For mezzanine debt there is no recorded lien on the building to rank, so the agreement instead governs the junior lender's pledge of the borrower's ownership interests and what the junior lender may collect while the senior loan is performing. Many ICAs let the junior lender keep receiving scheduled interest from the property's cash flow, and then cut that off when the senior loan is in default.

Cure rights and standstill

The mezzanine lender's most valuable right is the ability to pay the senior loan's overdue amounts itself. If the borrower defaults on the senior loan, the junior lender can step in and cure, which stops the senior lender from using its remedies. Law-firm summaries describe typical cure periods of about 15 days for a payment default and 30 days for other defaults, with longer extensions, in some deals 180 to 365 days, while the junior lender is diligently pursuing a cure. The cure period works as a standstill: during it the senior lender is barred from enforcing. The agreement may also limit how many times the same default can be cured and how many months in a row the junior lender may cover payments.

Purchase option

If the senior lender accelerates the loan, the ICA typically gives the mezzanine lender the right to buy it. The purchase price is generally the senior loan's outstanding principal plus accrued interest plus the costs the senior lender actually incurred, including protective advances. Default interest, exit fees and prepayment premiums are generally left out, because the senior lender is willing to be made whole, not to profit from the default. Owning the senior loan lets the junior lender control the workout instead of watching someone else run it.

Consent to modifications

A senior lender and borrower who agree to a loan change can hurt the junior lender without meaning to. A rate increase raises the payment the property must cover. A maturity extension delays the junior lender's refinance exit. A bigger loan pushes the junior loan further from the money. ICAs therefore generally require the junior lender's consent to specified senior modifications, and they often cap how much the senior loan can grow. Protective advances and interest that accrues are usually allowed without consent. See modification agreement for how a loan change is documented.

Transfers and qualified transferees

If the mezzanine lender forecloses on the pledged equity, it becomes the new owner of the borrower, and the senior lender is suddenly dealing with a stranger. ICAs typically let the mezzanine lender transfer the mezzanine loan, or take title in the foreclosure, without the senior lender's consent only if the transferee is a qualified transferee that meets stated eligibility requirements. Qualified transferees can include institutional lenders, real estate investment trusts and qualified institutional buyers. Because the pledge is personal property, the enforcement process is a UCC Article 9 sale, not a mortgage foreclosure; see UCC filing and capital stack.

Bankruptcy and replacement guarantors

More detailed ICAs also address a borrower bankruptcy (who may vote, who may file a claim), replacement of the guarantor if the guarantor's net worth falls, and replacement of the property manager. These matter little in a normal year and a great deal in a default.

Where you will see one

  • Mezzanine loans. The classic case: a senior mortgage plus a loan secured by the equity interests. Fannie Mae's Multifamily Guide, for example, requires an intercreditor agreement for each mortgage loan with mezzanine financing.
  • Second liens. A second mortgage on the same property needs the senior lender to agree to the second lien, and the subordination or intercreditor agreement records that agreement.
  • A/B notes. In CMBS and other syndicated loans, a single mortgage is split into a senior A-note and a subordinate B-note. The ICA between the note holders decides who controls servicing. The B-note holder typically has control until a control appraisal event, which occurs when appraisal reductions applied from the bottom up leave the holder secured by less than a stated share of its note, commonly described as 25%. Control then moves up the stack. See CMBS loan.
  • SBA 504. The third-party lender holds a first lien on the project and the CDC debenture, up to 40% of project cost, holds a second lien. SBA's Third Party Lender Agreement (Form 2287) sets the relationship, and under 13 CFR Part 120, Subpart H the third-party lender's lien is subordinate to the CDC's for prepayment penalties, late fees, other default charges and escalated post-default interest. See SBA 504 loans.
  • Preferred equity. Preferred equity is not debt, so a lender may use a related agreement, sometimes called a recognition agreement, to set out the investor's rights against the senior loan. See preferred equity.

Worked example

These are illustrative assumptions, not quotes, and they match the stack in capital stack. An investor buys a $20,000,000 property that produces $1,400,000 of net operating income. The deal has a $13,000,000 senior loan (65% of the price) at 6.5% interest-only, a $3,000,000 mezzanine loan at 12% interest-only, and $4,000,000 of equity. Combined leverage is $16,000,000, or 80%.

LayerAmountRateAnnual interestMonthly interest
Senior loan$13,000,0006.5%$845,000$70,417
Mezzanine loan$3,000,00012%$360,000$30,000
Total$16,000,0007.5% blended$1,205,000$100,417

NOI covers the combined interest 1.16 times, and covers the senior interest alone 1.66 times. Now suppose a major tenant leaves and NOI falls to $800,000. The senior interest of $845,000 is no longer covered, and the borrower misses two monthly senior payments.

Cure. Two missed payments are 2 × $70,417 = $140,833. Under a typical ICA the senior lender must notify the mezzanine lender of the default, and the mezzanine lender may pay that $140,833 (plus any late charges the senior documents impose) within the cure period. The senior lender cannot accelerate while that cure right is open. The mezzanine lender is not buying a building. It is paying $140,833 to protect a $3,000,000 position that would otherwise be wiped out in a senior foreclosure.

Purchase option. Suppose the senior lender instead accelerates. The ICA gives the mezzanine lender the right to buy the senior loan. Assume $13,000,000 of principal, one month of accrued interest of $70,417 and $60,000 of protective advances for property taxes. The price is $13,000,000 + $70,417 + $60,000 = $13,130,417. Default interest and prepayment fees are not included. The mezzanine lender now holds $16,130,417 of exposure and controls the senior loan itself, which lets it work out the deal with the borrower or enforce on the equity.

Why the math matters to you. Both paths keep the senior lender from foreclosing out from under the junior lender, and the second costs the mezzanine lender $13,130,417 of new money. That is why mezzanine lenders price in these rights and why a deal with no ICA in place would leave the senior lender free to foreclose. You can test the combined leverage on your own numbers with the LTV calculator and the debt yield test.

Why lenders care

For the senior lender, the ICA controls the junior lender. Without it, a mezzanine lender could enforce on the equity, install its own people at the borrower, file the borrower into bankruptcy or negotiate separately with the borrower, all while the senior lender is trying to collect. The senior lender therefore uses the ICA to limit those moves and to decide who can end up owning the property. A senior lender that does not like a proposed intercreditor will often refuse the junior financing altogether, which is why the junior capital has to be arranged with the senior lender's rules in mind.

For the junior lender, the ICA turns a loan with no recorded lien and no direct claim into something it can rely on: the right to cure, to buy, to be told about defaults, and to take title to the borrower in an orderly way. Its price for lending behind the senior loan is exactly the protections the ICA records, and that is why mezzanine terms are negotiated alongside the ICA and not before it.

Intercreditor vs. subordination agreement

The terms are used loosely, and the documents often overlap. A subordination agreement is generally the shorter document: a junior creditor agrees its debt and lien rank behind a senior creditor. An intercreditor agreement includes subordination and adds the procedures: standstill, cure and purchase rights, transfer limits and consent rules. A simple second lien may need only the first. Mezzanine and A/B structures almost always need the second.

What to watch for

  • Raise the intercreditor early. It needs two lenders and two law firms, and the borrower often pays for both. Open it when you sign the senior term sheet, not after the appraisal.
  • Read the senior lender's form first. Some senior lenders have a standard ICA and will not move far from it. Know what is negotiable before you pay for a mezzanine commitment.
  • Check the cure periods against your cash. If the junior lender's cure period is shorter than the time the borrower needs to sell a unit or finish a lease-up, the structure may default before the plan works.
  • Look at the cap on the senior loan. If the senior lender may increase the loan only by a small percentage without the junior lender's consent, a future refinance or an upsized loan could be blocked.
  • Know who the qualified transferees are. That list decides who can end up owning your property after a mezzanine foreclosure, and it is a bigger deal than it looks.
  • Ask what the ICA says about your guaranties. Some require replacing a guarantor or maintaining liquidity. See guarantor, non-recourse loan and bad boy carve-outs for how those obligations are layered.
  • Do not count on it as protection for you. The ICA binds the lenders to each other. It usually does not make the senior lender go easier on the borrower, and loan documents often cross-default, so trouble on one loan can become trouble on the other.

If you are adding junior capital to a deal, the first question is whether the senior lender will allow it and on what terms. Start a commercial real estate loan application and we will check the senior lender's position on junior debt before you pay for a second commitment. For the basics of how combined leverage is measured, read loan-to-value explained.

Sources: Fannie Mae Multifamily Selling and Servicing Guide, "Intercreditor Agreement" and "Mezzanine Financing" (mfguide.fanniemae.com); 13 CFR Part 120, Subpart H (ecfr.gov) and SBA Form 2287, Third Party Lender Agreement (sba.gov); law-firm practice guides on mezzanine intercreditor terms, including Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman, Dechert and Bass, Berry & Sims; Uniform Commercial Code Article 9 (law.cornell.edu/ucc/9). Cure periods, purchase price and control-appraisal thresholds are typical market terms that vary by deal. Example figures are illustrative assumptions and ignore fees and closing costs.

Frequently asked

What is an intercreditor agreement in commercial real estate?

It is a contract between two or more lenders that have claims against the same borrower or property. It sets their priority, limits what the junior lender can do, and spells out cure rights, purchase options and consent requirements. It is required whenever the capital stack includes both senior debt and subordinate debt such as mezzanine financing or a B-note.

Who signs an intercreditor agreement?

The senior lender and the junior lender sign it. The borrower, and often the mezzanine borrower entity, usually acknowledges it, but it is negotiated between the lenders and their law firms. The borrower often pays for both sides' legal costs, so ask for an estimate before you commit to the structure.

What is the difference between an intercreditor agreement and a subordination agreement?

A subordination agreement is a simpler document in which the junior creditor agrees to rank behind the senior one. An intercreditor agreement does that and also sets out how the two lenders deal with each other after a default: cure periods, standstill, purchase options, transfer rights and consent to modifications. Mezzanine deals use the longer intercreditor form because the junior loan is secured by equity interests, not by the real estate.

What is a mezzanine lender's cure right?

It is the right, but not the obligation, to pay what the borrower owes under the senior loan so the senior lender cannot enforce. Law-firm summaries describe typical periods of about 15 days for a monetary default and 30 days for a non-monetary default, with longer extensions while the mezzanine lender is diligently pursuing a cure. The actual periods are negotiated deal by deal.

Does a conventional bank loan with a second lien need an intercreditor agreement?

Usually something does. Many senior loan documents prohibit additional liens, so the second lender needs the senior lender's consent, and that consent is normally papered as a subordination or intercreditor agreement. If the first lender will not sign one, the second loan generally cannot close.

Does the SBA 504 program use an intercreditor agreement?

Yes, in effect. In a 504 project the third-party lender holds the first lien and the Certified Development Company's debenture holds a second lien, and the two lenders sign SBA's Third Party Lender Agreement (SBA Form 2287). Under 13 CFR Part 120, Subpart H, the third-party lender's lien is subordinate to the CDC's for items such as prepayment penalties, late fees and escalated default interest.

Related terms